Elia Raza
← All posts
Movies - I WatchNov 21, 20266 min readSpoiler-light

Captain America: The First Avenger Review: The Old-Fashioned Origin Doomsday Needs You to See

My Captain America: The First Avenger review: Chris Evans' earnest Steve Rogers, Peggy Carter, Bucky's start, and why the 2011 film matters for Avengers: Doomsday.

Chris Evans as Steve Rogers, in a trench coat over his Captain America costume, talking with Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter on a rainy USO stage in Captain America: The First Avenger
Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter in Captain America: The First Avenger — Marvel Studios / Paramount Pictures
Elia’s Rating

The most old-fashioned movie Marvel Studios has made, and that's exactly why it still works.

Directed by
Joe Johnston
Written by
Christopher Markus, Stephen McFeely (based on the Marvel comics by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby)
Starring
Chris Evans, Tommy Lee Jones, Hugo Weaving, Hayley Atwell, Sebastian Stan, Dominic Cooper, Toby Jones, Neal McDonough, Derek Luke, Stanley Tucci
Genre
SuperheroAdventureWar
Released
2011 · United States
Runtime
2h 4m
Rated
PG-13
Language
English
IMDb
6.9 / 10

Captain America: The First Avenger is the most old-fashioned movie Marvel Studios has made, and that's exactly why it still works. Chris Evans plays Steve Rogers with zero irony, Hayley Atwell's Peggy Carter is sharper than everyone around her, and the ending is the saddest thing in Phase One. With Evans and Atwell both back in December, this one has moved from "nice to have" to homework.

It's entry three in my Marvel movies to watch before Avengers: Doomsday list, and the first MCU film in the order after two Fox X-Men movies. Light spoilers only. I talk about the setup and the characters, and I keep the big moments vague.

What is Captain America: The First Avenger about?

It's 1942. Steve Rogers is a skinny, asthmatic kid from Brooklyn whom the Army keeps rejecting. Dr. Abraham Erskine (Stanley Tucci) sees something in him and picks him for a super-soldier experiment run by Colonel Chester Phillips (Tommy Lee Jones), Howard Stark (Dominic Cooper), and British agent Peggy Carter.

The serum works. Then the project falls apart, and Steve ends up selling war bonds in a costume until he decides to go rescue his best friend, Bucky Barnes, from behind enemy lines. The villain is Johann Schmidt, the Red Skull (Hugo Weaving), who runs Hydra and has stolen the Tesseract, a glowing cosmic cube with more power than he can handle.

Is Captain America: The First Avenger Worth Watching Today?

Yes, especially before Avengers: Doomsday. It holds an 80% Tomatometer from 275 reviews and a 75% Popcornmeter on Rotten Tomatoes (checked November 21, 2026). More to the point, it's where Steve, Peggy, and Bucky all start, and all three actors are tied to Doomsday.

What Works

Steve is good before he's strong. The best scene in the film has no superpowers in it. During training, Phillips tosses a dummy grenade at a group of recruits, everyone dives away, and the scrawny one jumps on it. That's the whole character in five seconds, and the movie trusts it. Evans plays Steve's decency straight. No smirk, no wink. Fifteen years of MCU snark later, that sincerity feels almost brave.

The war-bonds detour. I didn't expect a superhero movie to make fun of its own hero this early. Steve's first job as Captain America is a USO stage show with chorus girls and a prop shield, and it's both funny and a little sad. It also makes the switch to real soldier hit harder.

Peggy Carter. Atwell walks in and owns every scene. Peggy punches a recruit who mouths off on her first day, and she's the one who gets Steve onto the plane behind enemy lines. Their romance is mostly looks and half-finished sentences, which is why it hurts so much.

The ending. I won't spell it out, but the last stretch, a radio call between Steve and Peggy and a promised dance, is the emotional seed the MCU kept watering for eight years. It pays off in how Steve and Peggy's story ends in Endgame.

Pre-serum Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) in his Army training uniform at camp in Captain America: The First Avenger
Pre-serum Steve Rogers in Captain America: The First Avenger Marvel Studios / Paramount Pictures

What Doesn't Work

The Red Skull is a costume. Hugo Weaving does a fun, hammy accent, but Schmidt wants world domination because villains want world domination. Once the mask comes off, there's not much underneath.

The montage war. The Howling Commandos' Hydra raids get squashed into a montage. Bucky, Dum Dum Dugan, and the rest of the team barely get lines, so their friendship with Steve is something you're told about more than shown.

It feels like a setup for The Avengers in places. The present-day bookends and the final scene exist mostly to hand Steve over to the next movie. The film earns its ending, but you can feel the Marvel machine pulling him toward 2012.

Standout Performances

  • Chris Evans as Steve Rogers: the role he'd turned down more than once, per Wikipedia. He makes goodness look like a choice, not a default setting.

  • Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter: she got a TV series out of this performance, and you can see why within ten minutes.

  • Stanley Tucci as Dr. Erskine: warm, funny, and gone too soon. His late-night talk with Steve about why a weak man is the right pick is the film's thesis.

  • Tommy Lee Jones as Colonel Phillips: pure deadpan. He gets most of the best lines.

  • Sebastian Stan as Bucky Barnes: a small role here, but his Bucky is the confident big brother Steve wants to protect. His long road from sidekick to Winter Soldier to New Avenger starts in Brooklyn in this film.

Chris Evans as Steve Rogers and Sebastian Stan as Bucky Barnes in WWII gear in Captain America: The First Avenger
Steve Rogers and Bucky Barnes in Captain America: The First Avenger Marvel Studios / Paramount Pictures

How Captain America: The First Avenger Connects to Avengers: Doomsday

Avengers: Doomsday opens on December 18, 2026. Marvel lists Chris Evans as Steve Rogers, and Sebastian Stan is also in the official cast. At San Diego Comic-Con in July 2026, Hayley Atwell joined the cast onstage and confirmed her return as Peggy Carter. That's three of this film's leads.

Here's why that matters:

  1. Steve and Peggy are the heart of it. Endgame closed their story with that long-delayed dance. Doomsday reopening it means you need to know what they lost here.

  2. Bucky's starting point. Doomsday's Bucky has been brainwashed, rescued, and now runs with the New Avengers. You'll read his history better if you've seen who he was in 1943.

  3. The shield and what it stands for. Steve built the meaning of that shield in this film, and Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson now carries it. If you want the other end of that line, watch Sam Wilson's first film as Captain America.

  4. The Tesseract. The cosmic cube Schmidt chases here is the same one Loki steals in the next film, and it threads all the way through the Infinity Stone saga.

Hugo Weaving as the Red Skull holding the glowing blue Tesseract in Captain America: The First Avenger
The Red Skull with the Tesseract in Captain America: The First Avenger Marvel Studios / Paramount Pictures

Watch It If / Skip It If

Watch it if you're doing the full Doomsday order, you love a period adventure, or you want to understand why people cried at the end of Endgame. Coming straight from my X2 (2003) review, expect a big tonal shift: warmer, sillier, more hopeful.

Skip it if you've seen it recently and only want the essentials. You can survive Doomsday knowing "Steve was frozen in the 1940s and loved Peggy." But you'll feel it less.

Final Verdict

The First Avenger is a sincere, slightly creaky war adventure with a flat villain and a great hero. The first hour is the best Steve Rogers material Marvel ever made, and the ending still stings. If Doomsday brings Steve and Peggy back, this is the movie that makes that reunion mean something.

Previously: my X2 (2003) review

Next in the watch order: my The Avengers (2012) review

Questions, Answered

How long is Captain America: The First Avenger?

It runs 124 minutes, about 2 hours 4 minutes, according to Wikipedia. Disney+ lists 2h 6m with credits.

Who directed Captain America: The First Avenger?

Joe Johnston directed it. Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely wrote the screenplay, and Kevin Feige produced it.

What is Captain America: The First Avenger rated on Rotten Tomatoes?

It has an 80% Tomatometer from 275 reviews and a 75% Popcornmeter audience score (checked November 21, 2026).

Is Captain America: The First Avenger on Disney+?

Yes. It's streaming on Disney+ in the US as of November 21, 2026. Availability varies by country.

Thanks for reading — Elia
Share

Fight Me in the Comments

Agree, disagree, or tell me I have zero taste. Speak about your feelings, just don’t be a jerk.

Spoilers? Warn people first.
Next reviewThe X-Men Sequel That Still Beats Most Superhero Movies→